OTTR vs STRR

Otter Tail Corporation vs Star Equity Holdings, Inc. — Valuation Comparison 2026

By CirclFi Research Team · Updated 2026-06-03 · Data from SEC EDGAR, FRED & GDELT

Quick Summary — OTTR scores higher on quality with 7.6/10 vs STRR's 6.7/10. OTTR trades at $85.80 while STRR trades at $11.59. Both analyzed daily using SEC EDGAR data across 13 institutional models.

OTTR

Conglomerates
Otter Tail Corporation
Quality
7.6
out of 10
Value Trap
10
SAFE
Price
$85.80
Last close
Models
13/13
Active
VS

STRR

Conglomerates
Star Equity Holdings, Inc.
Quality
6.7
out of 10
Value Trap
25
LOW
Price
$11.59
Last close
Models
11/13
Active
OTTR
2 models active
Limited to 2/13 visible models
STRR
2 models active
Limited to 2/13 visible models

OTTR vs STRR — Fair Value Comparison

OTTR
$0$34$67$101 Price$85.80 Bayesian …$41.16 (-52.0%) Earnings …$48.67 (-43.3%)
STRR
$0$5$9$14 Price$11.59 Bayesian …$3.71 (-68.0%) Earnings …$7.93 (-16.5%)
Market Price Model 1 Model 2

Model-by-Model Comparison

ModelType OTTR Fair ValueOTTR Upside STRR Fair ValueSTRR Upside
Bayesian DCF Intrinsic $41.16 -52.0% $3.71 -68.0%
Earnings Power Value Intrinsic $48.67 -43.3% $7.93 -16.5%
EROIC Spread Intrinsic $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
First Chicago Scenario $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
Markov DDM Intrinsic $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
ML-RIV Intrinsic $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
Dynamic NAV Asset-Based $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
PWERM Option-Based $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
Regime Cross-Sectional Relative $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
Sentiment SOTP Hybrid $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
CUCE Ensemble Ensemble $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
FTNN Topology Relative $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%
RCMH-DCF Intrinsic $•••.•• ••.•% $•••.•• ••.•%

OTTR vs STRR — Which Stock Is More Undervalued in 2026?

OTTR scores higher with a 7.6/10 quality rating vs STRR's 6.7/10. Both stocks are analyzed daily using SEC EDGAR filings across 13 independent models.

How Do OTTR and STRR Valuations Compare?

At $85.80, OTTR trades +52.0% above its Bayesian DCF fair value of $41.16, while STRR at $11.59 trades +68.0% above its estimate of $3.71. STRR shows a wider gap between price and intrinsic value.

Quality of Company: OTTR vs STRR

OTTR earns a Quality of Company score of 7.6/10 compared to STRR's 6.7/10. The scores are closely matched, indicating similar fundamental quality profiles. The QOC score synthesizes 32 signals spanning profitability margins, revenue growth, free cash flow, capital allocation, and leverage.

Value Trap Risk: OTTR vs STRR

OTTR carries a SAFE value trap risk (10/100) while STRR shows LOW risk (25/100). Both companies show manageable value trap risk, suggesting their current valuations are not artificially depressed by fundamental deterioration.

Both in Conglomerates

Both OTTR and STRR operate in Conglomerates, which has 25 stocks tracked by CirclFi. Same-industry comparisons provide the most direct insight into relative valuation since both companies face similar regulatory environments, market dynamics, and competitive pressures. Both companies are analyzed with models spanning intrinsic (Bayesian DCF, EPV), scenario-based (First Chicago), regime-switching (Markov DDM, RCMH-DCF), machine learning (ML-RIV, FTNN), and ensemble methods (CUCE).

2 of 13 MODELS UNLOCKED

You’re comparing 2 models. 11 more have an opinion.

11 hidden models compare OTTR vs STRR differently — including EROIC Spread, First Chicago, Markov DDM, PWERM, and 7 more. Some may disagree with the 2 you see above.

11 additional fair values per stock Full confidence breakdown Live terminal — 5,000+ stocks

Bloomberg Terminal: ~$2,000/mo  ·  FactSet: ~$1,000/mo  ·  CirclFi: $0.90/day

See All 13 Models — $0.90/day

We don’t predict prices. We show you what 13 independent mathematical frameworks say a stock is worth — and let you decide.